Senior Pastor

Pastor Gregory Tolle

  Send Email  •  (918)825-0346

Greg came to First UMC in 2022.  He served as a youth minister for nine years before beginning to preach in 1995.  He has bachelors, masters, and doctoral degrees related to ministry and has served throughout Oklahoma and briefly in Texas.  Preaching and teaching are two of his passions.

Greg is married to Hadley, who is an elementary librarian at Sand Springs. They have two adult children. Their son, Spencer lives in Macon, GA, where he works for Good News TV in media tech. Their daughter, Bridget lives in Japan where she is an assistant English teacher and aspiring author. Outside of ministry, Greg enjoys cooking, traveling, being a "couch coach" for the Dallas Cowboys and the OU Sooners.

Director of Youth & Children Ministries

Colin McCartney

  Send Email  •  (918)825-0346

Colin McCartney is our new Director of Youth & Children Ministries. He enjoys attending sporting events, choir concerts, and theater shows to support the children and youth.

He is involved in the Design Team for camps, Youth Force, and enjoys helping to plan mission trips. Colin has a heart for missions; whether it is local or international. In 2011 and 2012 he went to Guatemala on a mission trip and is looking forward to being able to go again one day.

Colin grew up in Edmond, OK and graduated from Edmond Memorial High School in 2010.  After that he went to Rose State college for his associate's degree. He then graduated from Oklahoma City University with a degree in Sociology.

Colin met his wife Kirsten in 2017 at St. Marks UMC in Bethany. They were married in November 2019. They have two boys; Max, 11 years old & Miles, 9 years old. As a family, they enjoy attending the boys sporting events, watching movies, traveling, and finding new adventures. Family is important to the McCartney’s. Colin & Kirsten, also love pouring into their ministries together and work well as a team. Colin appreciates the support from the FUMC church family  towards his family.

Administrative Assistant

Lori McClellan

  Send Email  •  (918)825-0346

Lori came to Pryor UMC as Administrative Assistant in 2022.  She has been a lifelong Pryor resident, having graduated from Pryor High School in 1989.  Lori has two adult daughters who got married in 2023, 4 months and 1 day apart.  (WHEW!!!) lol.  Both girls and their spouses reside in Pryor.  Lori enjoys camping and fishing but her most favorite thing to do is spend time with her children.   

Preschool Director

Sherrill McPhearson

  Send Email


Summer McKinney